Skip to content
(844) 480-6028

Compare carriers

Home Insurance by Company

Every insurer prices home risk differently and shines for different owners. Compare top carriers on illustrative annual cost, financial strength, and what they do best.

  • Licensed agency partners nationwide
  • No effect on credit score
  • Free comparison
  • Compare 120+ carriers
Family in front of their insured suburban home

Quick answer

The best home insurance company depends on your home and priorities. USAA leads for military families, State Farm and Allstate offer strong agent networks and bundling, and regional carriers like Erie and Auto-Owners score high on service. Always compare quotes for your specific home.

Top home insurance companies

CompanyIllustrative / yrBest forDetails
Erie$1,620Homeowners in Erie’s regional footprint who value service.Erie review
USAA$1,680Military members, veterans, and their families.USAA review
Auto-Owners$1,700Homeowners who want a highly rated regional insurer via an agent.Auto-Owners review
State Farm$1,750Bundling home and auto with a local agent.State Farm review
Travelers$1,770Homeowners who want an established insurer and bundling.Travelers review
Nationwide$1,790Homeowners who want brand-new-belongings and bundling.Nationwide review
Allstate$1,820Homeowners who want optional add-ons and rewards.Allstate review
Farmers$1,850Homeowners who prefer an agent to tailor coverage.Farmers review
Liberty Mutual$1,880Homeowners who want highly customizable coverage.Liberty Mutual review

Estimated rates for illustration only — not a quote.

How to choose a home insurance company

Price matters, but so do claims service, financial strength, and coverage quality. Compare at least three carriers, check whether they offer replacement-cost coverage on your home and belongings, and confirm they write in your state. Then compare price. Use our home insurance comparison and calculator to get started.

You can also compare costs by state.

Last updated:

Home insurance company FAQs

Should I insure my home for market value or rebuild cost?

Homeowners insurance should be based on rebuild (replacement) cost — what it would take to rebuild the structure — not the market or sale price, which includes land value. Insuring to market value can leave you underinsured or overpaying.

Do I still need home insurance if I bought my house with cash?

It is not legally required without a mortgage, but going without it means you would pay entirely out of pocket for fire, storm, theft, or liability losses. Most owners keep coverage to protect their largest asset.

How do I insure a home I am building myself?

A home under construction is typically covered by a builder’s risk or a dwelling-under-construction policy, which protects materials and the structure during the build. You then convert to a standard homeowners policy once it is complete and occupied.

What is dwelling coverage and how much do I need?

Dwelling coverage (Coverage A) pays to repair or rebuild your home’s structure after a covered loss. Set it to your full rebuild cost — local construction cost per square foot times your home’s size — not the market price. Many policies also add an extended or guaranteed replacement-cost option to cover rebuild-cost spikes.

What does a standard homeowners policy not cover?

Common exclusions include flood, earthquake, normal wear and tear, pest damage, and sewer backup. Flood and earthquake need separate policies or endorsements, and sewer backup is often a low-cost add-on. Always read your exclusions.

How does my deductible affect my home insurance premium?

A higher deductible lowers your premium because you absorb more of a small claim. Going from a $1,000 to a $2,500 or $5,000 deductible can noticeably cut cost — just keep that amount in savings. Many coastal states also apply a separate percentage-based hurricane or wind deductible.

Does home insurance cover my roof?

Yes, for sudden covered perils like storms or fire, though older roofs may be settled at actual cash value (depreciated) rather than replacement cost. Some carriers offer better roof replacement endorsements. Routine age-related wear is not covered.

Ready to see how much you could save?

Compare personalized quotes from top carriers in minutes — free and with no obligation.

  • Licensed agency partners nationwide
  • No effect on credit score
  • Free comparison
  • Compare 120+ carriers
Get Free Quotes Call